In the last blog I discussed the premise of Hunger Games. For this blog let’s do as Jules from Pulp Fiction said, “Get into character.” The main character is Katniss Everdeen. A girl from District 12 who is poor, and has learned how to hunt with a bow and arrow when her father died to support her family. This character sucks, and it’s really hard to believe her emotions are that of a 16 years old girl. Oh and she is also a virgin. Apparently in the future people no longer like sex. She is self-serving which is understandable in this situation and in the middle of a love triangle which is completely unbelievable.
One point of the triangle is her pseudo-boyfriend Gale. I said pseudo because they never hook-up. Apparently in the future teenagers are not curious about sex either. But they do hunt together. The other end of this triangle is Peeta. Also in the future people get weird names. He is a sap and in love with Katniss. And unlike in reality the sap will ultimately end up with the girl. However, throughout the entire series Katniss acts like she doesn’t like Peeta. In fact she really acts like she doesn’t like either. This love triangle is about as steamy as dull steel. I can only explain its purpose in the series to fulfill this young adult cliché of love triangles—Harry Potter, Twilight. But unlike how those triangles were believable and passionate, this one just goes through the motions, with her ending up with Peeta and the reader asking what?
There are other characters and they are also cliché—the drunk mentor, the superficial host for the game show, the evil president, the innocent sister. Do not expect any surprises from this group or even any character development throughout the series. In fact Katniss herself after all the hell she went through in these Hunger Games, votes to put the children of the Capital in a similar Hunger Games once a year at the end of the third book. This is equivalent of after reading a novel that focuses and expresses the horrors of a war, the main character then saying he loves war. Charlie Sheen’s character in Platoon re-enlisting for Vietnam.
So enough with the lame characters lets finish this blog up with the plot. In the first book Katniss of course wins the hunger games. She is never confronted with having to make a difficult decision and having to kill someone she doesn’t want to—which would be the obvious moral conundrum in this premise you would expect, but alas it never takes place. She befriends a young girl Rue (again weird names like we have left Earth and are now in Mordor). Now if Katniss killed Rue this could have been a scene to make this trilogy immortal. Like George and Lennie in “Of Mice and Men,” you know a real tough decision. But no, one of the “bad” competitors kills her, and of course only these bad competitors Katniss kills. Throughout the time in the arena Katniss has had to act like she genuinely loved Peeta, so that they could get the support of sponsors that drops off medical aid and gifts. Peeta of course genuinely loves her so he is being played for a sucker, but it also saves his life. When it gets down to just her and Peeta, and the dramatic conclusion, she gives Peeta a handful of poisonous berries that she also about to take for herself. They say they love each other too much to kill one another. Katniss’s real strategy is that she believes the capital needs a winner and won’t let them both die. And of course this is true. The capital stops them from killing themselves and allows them both to live, because there has to be a winner. Really? Throughout the entire time in the “arena” the capitol has sent these man made destructions: fireballs, mechanical animals, etc, to kill the competitors if the games got boring but now they can’t do any of them to at least kill either Peeta or Katniss? They have to have a champion. This logic doesn’t hold up to, well, logic. But then again neither does the rest of the story.
In the second book it becomes apparent that since Katniss refused to kill Peeta, and they both attempted suicide instead of killing each other they have stirred rebellion in Panem. Really? 75 years of Hunger Games, dirt poor living conditions, no freedom that doesn’t stir a revolt, but two teenagers about to eat berries does? What the hell kind of people are living in Panem? So Katniss becomes the symbol of the revolution, the “Mocking Jay” and now she is a threat to the capitol. So for the 75th Hunger Games, old champions are returned and of course that means Katniss and Peeta—also Panem thinks Katniss and Peeta have a real love story going—and this also means you will be reading the same book twice. Most of the book again is in the arena. This time Katniss will let Peeta live and kill herself if it comes down to those two. But this again never happens. Instead at the very end via deus ex machina (something in storytelling that I really hate) Katniss and a few others competitors escape the arena thanks to a few members of an underground revolution. It comes as a surprise to the reader because even though these other members knew of it along with her drunk mentor no one told Katniss or Peeta about this planned escape on the third day of the Hunger Games. Sure this allows the reader to be surprised, but it again doesn’t hold up to any logic. If Katniss is so important to the revolution’s cause why not let her in on this planned escape? She will be prepared, she will avoid killing someone who is also in on the plot, and generally for something so important to be this successful you would not leave it to just dumb luck that she survives. But that would not allow for such a surprise. So for the sake of suspense—which is the only thing these novels carry through on—logic is again sacrificed.
The third book is by far the most disappointing of the three. Apparently there is a district 13 that has been allowed to survive since their failed rebellion just as long as no one knows about them because they have nuclear weapons. Yeah, really process this: one district has all the nukes for what reason we never now because we have no idea about other countries, if a nuclear war caused this holocaust, and why the hell if they are the only ones with nukes they just don’t just nuke the capital. But whatever, we suspended common sense after the first chapter of the first book so why stop now. Katniss escapes to District 13, but not Peeta, because no one told him there would be an escape. So he is prisoner, and in this book she spends most of the time with Gale, who was mostly absent from the first two. But these two have about zero chemistry between them romantically. Again, worst love triangle ever. Collins should have checked out Bull Durham. And now the revolution is full on, and the leaders of the crusade are Katniss and Gale. Now I know she was awesome being in the arena but I tend to believe the best soldiers would be 25-35 year old men with extensive training. A team of prom queens didn’t kill Osama Bin Laden, navy seals did. Yet they are leading the revolt, but yet whenever something big happens, she is knocked out or we are told through other people. While the most explosive shit is happening in the trilogy on the outside, most of the book is Katniss dealing with her emotions internally. Peeta is captured, and when he returns he is broken. Yet the events play out were a group of the arena’s combatants that escaped travel to the capital for the final death blow. People die, but not Katniss, Gale, or even Peeta who as deranged as he is, is also on this important mission. They capture President Snow, and Katniss’s younger sister Prim dies in the attack. Prim was originally chosen for the games in the first book but Katniss took her place to save her—a hollow sacrifice, but this is the only hard part to read that makes this series to have not too much of a happy ending. Snow gets captured, and Katniss is set to execute him. It is during this that Katniss votes to have a Hunger Games for the children of the capital now that they are defeated. A move that goes against any type of character development throughout the series and just makes the reader again ask what? When she goes to kill Snow, Katniss instead kills the leader of the revolution President Coin, because it was her plan to drop the bombs that had killed Prim. Yeah read the book for a better explanation of events but again it’s just cruel, to have Prim die, and again makes no sense. So then Katniss is taken away, put in a room, then her mentor who has battled alcoholism comes and tells her that her trial for killing Coin is over, and she is good to. Can I get another what? Fifteen years later she is married to Peeta and they have children. The ultimate what. Most readers thought she would at least end up with Gale, and Peeta was just a sap.
The books ends with the sentence “There are much worse games to play.” True but there are also much better series to read. My recommendation is to get into the Song of Fire and Ice by George R.R. Martin, otherwise known as the Game of Thrones series. Just fucking awesome. Not written for kids, and although this takes place in another universe, these characters are much more human than anyone you will find in the Hunger Games.